Back to Insights
Recruitment Strategy

Why Physicians Decline Job Offers, and What Employers Can Change

About three in ten physician offers are declined. Here are the reasons candidates say no, what our own offers show so far this year, and what an employer can change before the next one goes out.

Why Physicians Decline Job Offers, and What Employers Can Change

About three in ten physician job offers are declined. The Association for Advancing Physician and Provider Recruitment, whose members are in-house recruiters at hospitals and health systems, found that 70.6 percent of physician offers were accepted in its 2025 benchmarking report, and the rate has sat near 70 percent since 2018. For the employer, a decline is the most expensive moment in a search. The sourcing, the interviews, and the site visit are already spent, the position is still open, and every additional day has a price.

This page looks at declines from the hiring side. The figures come from offers MedStaff Nationwide clients extended to physicians, nurse practitioners, and physician assistants in 2026, the same records behind our Offer Report. We do not publish the reasons individual candidates gave. Those are recorded in their own words and stay private. Instead we compare the terms and timing of the offers that were accepted with the ones that were declined, in aggregate, and withhold any comparison that rests on fewer than 10 decided offers on either side.

84%
of decided 2026 offers were accepted
38 accepted and 7 declined. The national benchmark for physician offers is 70.6%.
Physician offers accepted
80%
5 decided offers
NP and PA offers accepted
93%
27 decided offers
Median days from presentation to offer
20
6 decided offers

What separated the offers that were accepted

The term-by-term comparison (base against the quoted range, speed to offer, a decision date, sign-on, loan repayment, relocation, tail coverage) appears here once at least 10 decided offers stand on each side of a question. With 45 offers decided so far, none has reached that floor, and a comparison built on fewer would say more about two or three negotiations than about the market.

Share of decided offers accepted by specialty, 2026
ItemShareAcceptedOffers
Therapist56%12 offers
Nurse Practitioner90%12 offers
Family Practice100%8 offers
Physician80%7 offers

The national picture: who hears no most often

The AAPPR benchmark breaks the acceptance rate down by the kind of organization making the offer. The differences are small, which is the point: no category of employer is exempt. Rural organizations were too few in the sample to report.

Share of physician job offers accepted, by employer (AAPPR 2025 benchmarking report)
ItemShareAccepted
Academic and university hospitals74%
Multihospital and integrated systems72.6%
Multispecialty and ambulatory practices70.4%
750 or more clinicians73.8%
200 to 749 clinicians66.8%
Fewer than 200 clinicians71.2%
Serving urban areas72.3%
Serving suburban areas68%

Candidates can afford to be selective. The same American Medical Association report cites AMN Healthcare's survey of final-year residents, in which 56 percent had received 100 or more job solicitations during training. AAPPR's chief executive told the AMA that candidates are rejecting more offers, interviewing in more places at once, and slowing the process while they wait for every offer to arrive so they can compare them.

Seven reasons physicians turn an offer down

The reasons a candidate gives for a decline fall into a small number of categories. None is exotic, and most are visible before the offer goes out.

1. A competing offer arrived first

A physician interviewing with you is usually interviewing elsewhere at the same time. The organization that takes three weeks to turn a good site visit into a written offer is being compared with one that took one. Speed is the only part of this an employer controls, and it is free.

2. The written offer did not match the conversation

A base lower than the range discussed, a bonus mentioned on the phone and missing from the letter, a call schedule heavier than the one described at the site visit. A surprise in writing reads as bad faith even when it is an oversight, and it ends negotiations that a lower number stated up front would not have.

3. Base was below the market and nothing else closed the gap

Candidates compare offers on base first. An employer whose scale cannot move has other lines that can: sign-on, relocation, loan repayment where the site qualifies, a longer guarantee period. Our Offer Report shows how often each appeared this year, and the sign-on bonus report covers how bonuses are sized and structured.

4. Questions about the job itself were never answered

Call frequency, patient volume, the schedule, how many advanced practice providers the physician will supervise, and why the last person left. When those answers are vague in the third interview, candidates assume the true answers are unattractive.

5. The contract carried a term the candidate would not sign

A wide non-compete, a sign-on clawback with no proration, claims-made malpractice with tail left to the physician, termination without cause on short notice. Candidates are advised to read for exactly these terms, and their attorneys find them. Our contract checklist shows what candidates are told to look for.

6. The decision was not only the candidate's

A partner's career, schools, distance from family, and whether the community felt like somewhere they could live. A site visit that schedules eight hours with the medical staff and nothing for the person relocating with the physician leaves the deciding vote uncast.

7. The process itself was the warning

Rescheduled interviews, a week of silence after the site visit, different answers from different leaders. Candidates read the hiring process as a preview of how the organization runs, and they are usually right to.

What to change before the next offer goes out

  • Settle the deal-breakers before the first interview. Schedule, call, volume, supervision, and the compensation model should have one answer, and everyone the candidate meets should give it.
  • Quote a range early and offer inside it. If the offer has to come in below what the candidate was told, say so and say why before the letter arrives.
  • Put the whole package in the first written offer. Base, sign-on, relocation, loan repayment, PTO, CME, malpractice type, and who pays for tail. Terms added after a decline are worth less than the same terms offered first.
  • Move from final interview to written offer in days. Make the verbal offer the same week and follow it with the letter. Get committee approval for the range before the site visit, not after it.
  • Name a decision date and ask what else they are weighing. You will learn whether you are the first choice, and which term would make you one.
  • Plan the site visit for two people. Time with a realtor, a look at schools, dinner with a physician's family who made the same move.
  • Read your own contract first. Find the terms that end negotiations before the candidate's attorney does, and decide in advance which ones you will bend on.

After a decline: revise once, or move on

Ask for the reason the same day, while the candidate is still willing to give a straight answer, and write it down. If the reason is a term you can change, revise once, quickly, and in writing. If the reason is location, a partner's job, or an offer already accepted elsewhere, a better number rarely changes the answer and costs you days with the next candidate.

The larger protection is never having only one candidate. Keep the second finalist informed and interested until the first has signed, not until the first has been offered.

What a decline costs

A declined offer sends the search back to the second finalist if there is one, and back to sourcing if there is not. Nationally, physician searches active in 2025 took a median of 119 days to fill and the typical physician started work 229 days after the position was posted. Each week added to that is a week of the revenue the role would have produced. Our vacancy cost calculator turns it into a figure for your specialty.

MedStaff Nationwide is a contingency physician recruitment firm. Before an offer goes out on one of our searches, the recruiter benchmarks it against what the candidate has told us they are weighing and against offers in the same specialty this year, so the first written offer is the one most likely to be signed. If you have an offer in draft or a search that has already lost a candidate, tell us about the role.

The comparison on this page updates as offers are recorded and refreshes daily. Figures resting on fewer than 5 offers, and comparisons with fewer than 10 decided offers on either side, are withheld. The full package terms behind these offers are in the Offer Report.

Frequently asked questions

What percentage of physician job offers are accepted?
About 70 percent. The Association for Advancing Physician and Provider Recruitment's 2025 benchmarking report found 70.6 percent of physician job offers were accepted the previous year, and the rate has stayed near 70 percent since 2018 apart from a rise during the pandemic. Roughly three offers in ten are declined.
Why do physicians turn down job offers?
Most declines trace to one of seven causes: a competing offer arrived first, the written offer did not match what was discussed, base pay was below the market and the rest of the package did not close the gap, questions about call, schedule, and workload were never answered, the contract carried a term the candidate would not sign, a partner or family could not make the move work, or the hiring process itself made the organization look disorganized. Most of these are visible before the offer goes out.
How long should a physician have to decide on an offer?
Long enough to review the contract with an attorney and talk it through at home, and short enough that the offer does not drift. Offer and negotiation typically take one to three weeks. State a decision date in the written offer and ask what else the candidate is weighing; an open-ended offer invites the candidate to wait for every other offer to arrive.
Should we revise an offer after a physician declines it?
Only when the reason is a term you can change, such as base, sign-on, tail coverage, or call, and only once, quickly, and in writing. If the reason is location, a partner's career, or a competing offer already accepted, a revision rarely changes the answer and delays the next candidate.
Where does the offer data on this page come from?
From offers recorded in MedStaff Nationwide's placement system as clients extended them to candidates we presented during the year, the same records behind our Offer Report. The page publishes aggregates only. It does not publish the reasons individual candidates gave, and a comparison appears only when at least ten decided offers stand on each side of it.